Skip to main content

Solution to Krypton 185

Today's clue:

Keeper, not his brother's keeper,  has doubts, kills first brother  violently  (9)

Its solution:  CUSTODIAN
CAIN + DOUBTS - B

In a biblical story Cain killed his brother Abel and when God  asked about Abel  responded "Am I my brother's keeper?"

Here is the list of answers received today.


Comments

I got the breakdown and got the fodder for anagram. But could not form the anagram to make custodian.

Very nice clue.

Both uthirivedi and krypton had fratricide!
Vanchinathan said…
It was a deliberate attempt. First I did the Krypton. Then thought about a similar situation in Tamil/Indian context. All over the word at all times people have killed brothers!
The secular reading of the Cain and Abel story is this: It is the folk memory of the conflict between herders and farmers. Herders own the animals, not the land. Farmers claim ownership of land. Thus they were in deep conflict. Science says agriculture developed in the Israel region 11000 years ago with the domestication of goats and then sheep. After few thousand years wheat was domesticated there. Around 8000 years ago.

The earliest form of Cain and Abel story is in Egyptian mythology. Same story, both the farmer (Cain) and the herder (Abel) made sacrifices. God accepted the herder's sacrifice. The farmer killed the herder. The earliest reference is 5000 years ago. Oral tradition for 3000 years is quite possible.

The most intriguing reference I found in Mahabaratham is "In the King Dushyandan's time there were no farmers, there were no miners". Traditional interpretation is bhoomi devi gave everything to everyone without having to work. My personal interpretation, is Dushyandan was the last herding king. His son/descendant Bharatan founded the farming kingdom. Farming produces a population explosion and expands rapidly by population expansion and settlement. Thus all the local chiefs of the settlements claim descent from Bharatan to legitimatize their right to rule that settlements. Thus the entire sub continent became bharatam.
Vanchinathan said…
I did not know about this farmer vs herder conflicts. Thanks for the info. Is it correct to interpret no farming to mean no work? Possibly it meant people did hunting to get their food.

I read somewhere that "agriculture" is an artificial activity. AT least to grow rice/paddy one has to make lot of unnatural activity. Keeping the field waterlogged always, and weeding out. Forgot the name of a Japanese farming method which is natural, Fukoka or something like that.

Popular posts from this blog

உதிரிவெடி 4265

உதிரிவெடி 4264 (நவம்பர் 12, 2023) வாஞ்சிநாதன் ************************ அனைவருக்கும் தீபாவளி வாழ்த்துகள் தீபாவளியில் அமவாசைக்கு நன்றாகத் தேய்ந்து இல்லாமற் போன நிலவு நாளில் யோசிக்க இன்றைய புதிர்: வெற்றியிழந்து மெய் தேயத் தொடக்கம் (5) விடைகள் நாளை காலை 6 மணிக்கு வெளியிடப்படும். உங்கள் விடையை இடுவதற்கு இங்கே சொடுக்கி வேறிடம் செல்லவும்  

உதிரிவெடி 4281

உதிரிவெடி 4281 (பிப்ரவரி 18, 2024) வாஞ்சிநாதன் ************************ வேழத்தால் எருமையிடமிருந்து பெறப்பட்டது என்பது சரியில்லை (5) விடைகள் தாமதமாக நாளை இரவு 9 மணிக்கு வெளியிடப்படும். உங்கள் விடையை இடுவதற்கு இங்கே சொடுக்கி வேறிடம் செல்லவும்  

உதிரிவெடி 4277

உதிரிவெடி 4277 (ஜனவரி 21, 2024) வாஞ்சிநாதன் ************************ ஊரில் ஊரின் மையத்தைச் சுற்றி வரும் கோடு (3) விடைகள் நாளை காலை 6 மணிக்கு வெளியிடப்படும். உங்கள் விடையை இடுவதற்கு இங்கே சொடுக்கி வேறிடம் செல்லவும்